Quiz: Should I Get a Dog or a Cat?

By: Brianna Gunter | Published Dec 19, 2023

You know you want a pet to add joy and companionship to your life, but which is the more suitable species: dog or cat? Despite almost a quarter of pet owners having both a dog and a cat these days, the feline vs. canine debate seems never-ending and can get quite contentious depending on who you talk to. The truth is that both cats and dogs are awesome, though it's important to acknowledge that individual pets — even those among the same species and breed — can vary greatly in temperament and personality.

Of course, it all starts with you deciding between a dog and a cat in the first place. Even if you're equipped to handle the needs of both, one could be a better fit for your lifestyle than the other.

Differences between cats and dogs

While dogs and cats have a lot of similarities as human companions, they do come with some key differences that are worth considering when deciding which one is right for you. Both dogs and cats can form strong bonds with pet owners, but there are nuanced differences worthy of consideration.

Dogs are often seen as higher maintenance, requiring daily walks and exercise sessions, not to mention needing to go outdoors for potty time. However, they are often more responsive to hand signals and voice command training than cats. Dogs tend to make great outdoor buddies — from agile adventurers to neighborhood strollers — due to their trainability and exercise needs. Cats are meanwhile more independent than dogs on average, but they still require daily litterbox cleanings as well as plenty of toys and climbing spaces to keep them occupied and getting enough exercise indoors. While many cats make for loving, cuddly companions, they may not be as responsive to "trick" training and may desire more solo time than dogs. 

Again, it's still worth considering that pets all have their own interests and unique quirks. One Beagle could love playing fetch in the snow, while another Beagle could have a strong preference for warm, indoor-only activities. Part of the fun of having a pet is getting to know their personality and what makes them special!

Quiz: are you a dog person or cat person?

Not sure if a dog or cat is right for you? Take this 12-question quiz for a better idea — you might surprise yourself! Grab a pencil and some paper to jot down the letters to each answer as you go.

1. Are you able to have pets in your home?

1. Yes, dogs are fine. Cats are probably fine too and/or I don't know about cats.
2. Yes, but only cats are allowed.
3. Sure can! Both dogs and cats are welcome, and I have a lot of space.
4. No, not really. But what my landlord doesn't know won't hurt them, right?

2. Alright, be honest — how physically active are you?

1. I like to get at least some exercise in every day, even if it's light.
2. I like to be active at least a few times a week, but I enjoy my couch time.
3. I'm very active and always seem to have some energy to burn!
4. Eh, it's not really my thing. I'm a creature of comfort.

3. How much time are you willing to spend on training?

1. As much time as it takes for my pet to be safe and social. I'm even open to pet training classes.
2. A decent amount, though I'm really hoping it won't take over my life.
3. Are you kidding? A lot! Training's one of the things I look forward to the most!
4. A little, I guess. I don't really know a ton about pet training, to be honest.

4. If you had to choose, what kind of waste clean-up do you prefer?

1. It's best if it stays outside. I don't want to deal with that in the home.
2. I prefer it all be in one place so I can clean up in one go.

5. How much time do you like to spend outdoors?

1. I love going outdoors! If I could live out in nature, I would.
2. I'm much more of a homebody. All my favorite stuff is inside!
3. I prefer a nice, even mix of indoor and outdoor time.
4. I don't actually have a ton of time to go do anything, so I'm not sure.

7. All pets need grooming! How much are you willing to do?

1. I'm ready to commit to regular baths. Heck, I might even look at professional groomer options for help.
2. Some regular brushing is great, but I'm not looking forward to bath time.
3. I consider grooming time a form of bonding between me and my pet. Fill the tub and hand me the brush!
4. The less grooming, the better. Those hairless pets are low maintenance, right?

8. If you're being honest, how big of a pet do you want?

1. Probably something medium-sized. Big pets are neat though.
2. Small is best for me — not sure if I could manage a big pet.
3. I have plenty of space and energy, so pet size isn't really an issue.
4. I don't know. Personality matters most though, right?

9. How much time do you want to spend with your pet?

1. The more time, the better! Really looking forward to having a buddy.
2. A ton of time, but I'm fine with us having occasional breaks from one another.
3. I'm so excited to hang out with my pet, even if they're distracted by something/someone else.
4. I have limited time during the day, so I'm not really sure.

10. How social would you describe yourself?

1. Pretty social. I really like getting out in public.
2. I enjoy my alone time.
3. I'm always down to go out, but I like quiet moments too.
4. I'm not sure — I thought this quiz was about pets?

11. Almost there! Do you like dogs in general?

1. I do! Dogs are the best!
2. Some are cool I guess, but a bit much at times.
3. Oh yes — dogs are great, and I've had one before.
4. I think so? I haven't actually met many dogs.

12. Last one! Do you like cats in general?

1. Um. Not really.
2. Yes! Cats are so funny and awesome.
3. Absolutely! I've had a cat before and they were great.
4. I'm a bit scared of the claws, so I'm not sure.

Results

Ready to discover if a dog or cat may be the more ideal addition to your life? Take a moment to tally up how many of each letter you wrote down. 

Mostly As: Congratulations; you're a dog person! You're a caring person who wants to share the love, and you're looking forward to getting outside every day. Dogs come in a wide range of sizes and energy levels, so now's a great time to start exploring different breed options and learning more about all the great things dogs have to offer. When you do find your canine friend, be sure to protect their health before you set out on your adventures. 

Mostly Bs: Hooray! A cat could just be the purr-fect new friend for you! You're a self-sufficient person looking for an independent pet, though you love curling up at home at the end of a long day. Though of course, you're still looking forward to dangling cat toys and watching some crazy impressive acrobatics. Just remember that cats are unpredictable, regardless of breed. No matter what kind of kitty you welcome into your life, be sure to protect against surprises early on. 

Mostly Cs: You just love pets, and you adore everything that both dogs and cats have to offer. Either animal would be lucky to be your companion, and if you have the space and the means, you may even want to consider welcoming both a dog and a cat into your home! Just be sure to do your research and talk with friends and family members who have multiple pets — two pets are a lot of responsibility. Dogs and cats may likewise need some extra help being introduced to coexist peacefully, and they will also require different types of care and training. But if you're a patient person and are prepared 

Mostly Ds: You're not quite sure yet if you're ready for any pet right now, and that's okay. Pet ownership is fun and rewarding, but it is also a huge decision that should never be made on a whim. This is an opportunity to get to know more about the ins and outs of caring for a pet and learning more about the responsibilities involved. Talk to friends and family members with pets about all the pros and cons, and consider volunteering at local animal shelters. You may also want to call a breeder or veterinary office if you are considering certain breeds. Exploring more Pet Parenting articles can also help you get a better idea of the health and wellness needs dogs and cats have throughout their lifetimes.

Like pet quizzes? Why not take another one? Find out which dog breed size could be the best fit in your life.